Customer Favorites

Customer Favorites

New to Con' Olio? Start with our customer favorites. 

These are the oils and vinegars our customers come back for year after year.  

  • Barrel Aged Sicilian Lemon Balsamic Vinegar

    Barrel Aged Sicilian Lemon Balsamic Vinegar

    Experience the vibrant essence of Modena with our Sicilian Lemon Balsamic Vinegar, a zesty and fresh culinary delight that adds a cheerful twist to your dishes. This unique balsamic vinegar is perfect for enhancing everything from fresh salads to savory...

    $8.00 - $41.00
  • Barrel Aged Traditional 18-YR Balsamic Vinegar of Modena

    Barrel Aged Traditional 18-YR Balsamic Vinegar of Modena

    Our #1 top seller year over year! Our premium aged balsamic vinegar from Modena, Italy, is crafted in the traditional style using the purest traditions. It matures up to 18 years using the Solera System in barrels made of chestnut, oak, mulberry, and ash...

    $6.99 - $42.99
  • Barrel-Aged Summer Peach Balsamic

    Barrel-Aged Summer Peach Balsamic

    Transform your culinary creations with our exquisite Summer Peach Balsamic Vinegar, crafted from premium White Trebbiano Grape Must. This Aged White Peach Balsamic boasts a crisp, refreshing flavor profile that captures the essence of juicy, ripe peaches...

    $8.00 - $41.00
  • Butter Olive Oil-Dairy Free-VEGAN

    Butter Olive Oil-Dairy Free-VEGAN

    Revolutionize your cooking with our Butter Olive Oil – a delicious, dairy-free alternative that brings the rich, creamy flavor of butter without any animal products. Made from Ultra Premium Virgin Olive Oil, each drop delivers a luxurious buttery...

    $7.00 - $41.00
  • California Arbequina Extra Virgin Olive Oil-Mild

    California Arbequina Extra Virgin Olive Oil-Mild

    MILD INTENSITY-Crush Date: Nov 2025 Experience the rich flavors of our NEW California Arbequina Extra Virgin Olive Oil, a delightfully mild cooking oil perfect for elevating all your culinary creations. This ultra premium extra virgin oil captures the...

    $7.99 - $44.99
  • Garlic Olive Oil

    Garlic Olive Oil

    Our Top Selling EVOO year over year! Transform your culinary creations with the robust flavor of our Garlic Olive Oil, a must-have for garlic enthusiasts everywhere. This exquisite blend of Ultra Premium Extra Virgin Olive Oil infused with fresh garlic...

    $8.00 - $45.00
  • Italian Tuscan Herb Olive Oil

    Italian Tuscan Herb Olive Oil

    The one customers come back for again and again. Bold, savory, and instantly transforms anything you're cooking. Crafted from Certified Ultra Premium Extra Virgin Olive Oil, this exquisite infusion combines the rich aromas of oregano, rosemary, marjoram,...

    $7.99 - $44.99
  • Lemon Olive Oil-Whole Fruit Fused

    Lemon Olive Oil-Whole Fruit Fused

    Our Fused Portuguese early harvest lemon olive oil is made with Arbosana olives and freshly picked Lunario and Eureka Lemons harvested locally.  The resulting fusion is bright, zesty and fresh with a pleasing lingering pepper finish. This fused oil...

    $8.00 - $45.00
  • Spanish Manzanillo Extra Virgin Olive Oil-Robust

    Spanish Manzanillo Extra Virgin Olive Oil-Robust

    ROBUST INTENSITY-*Crush Date: Nov 2025 Experience the unmatched quality of Manzanillo Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Spain, characterized by its robust intensity and rich flavor profile. Perfect for both culinary enthusiasts and health-conscious consumers,...

    $7.99 - $44.99